Reviews When She Returned by Lucinda Berry

Have you ever picked up a book that you thought would be a quick, thrilling read, only to find yourself lost in its pages, questioning everything you thought you knew about family, identity, and the human psyche? That’s exactly what happened to me when I stumbled upon Lucinda Berry’s “When She Returned” during one of my late-night writing sessions.

As an aspiring novelist myself, I’m always on the lookout for stories that push the boundaries of conventional storytelling. When I read the premise of Berry’s book – a woman vanishing for 11 years, only to reappear with an infant in tow – I was instantly intrigued. Little did I know that this psychological thriller would not only captivate me but also challenge my own approach to writing.When She Returned by Lucinda Berry2

From the very first page, I was drawn into the complex web of emotions and secrets that Berry weaves. The story, told from multiple perspectives – Kate (the returned woman), Abbi (her daughter), and Meredith (her husband’s new wife) – is a masterclass in narrative tension. As I flipped through the pages, I found myself constantly shifting allegiances, questioning motives, and reevaluating my own assumptions.

One of the aspects that struck me most was Berry’s exploration of cult psychology. There’s a particular scene where Kate recounts her indoctrination that left me breathless. Berry writes:

“It wasn’t about believing in their god or their prophecies. It was about belonging, about finally feeling seen and valued. And once they had that hook in you, the rest was easy.”

This passage haunted me for days, making me ponder the fine line between faith and manipulation, between seeking connection and losing oneself. As someone who’s always been fascinated by human behavior, I found myself scribbling notes in the margins, ideas for my own writing sparked by Berry’s insights.

However, I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention some of the book’s shortcomings. At times, the pacing felt uneven, particularly in the middle sections. There were moments when I wanted to urge the characters forward, to push them towards the revelations I knew were coming. Additionally, some of the plot twists, while shocking, stretched the bounds of believability. As a writer, I understand the temptation to go for the jaw-dropping reveal, but I couldn’t help but feel that sometimes, subtlety can be more powerful.

That being said, Berry’s prose is undeniably engaging. Her ability to capture the nuances of human emotion is remarkable. There’s a moment when Abbi, now a teenager, grapples with the return of the mother she barely remembers. Berry writes:

“I wanted to hate her. I wanted to love her. Most of all, I wanted to understand her.”

This line resonated deeply with me, encapsulating the complex emotions that run through the entire novel. It reminded me of the importance of emotional authenticity in writing, something I strive for in my own work.

As I read, I couldn’t help but draw parallels to my own writing process. Berry’s skill in maintaining tension throughout the narrative is something I aspire to in my stories. Her use of multiple perspectives to reveal different facets of the truth is a technique I’ve experimented with, but seeing it executed so effectively in “When She Returned” has inspired me to push my own boundaries further.

One of the most thought-provoking aspects of the book for me was its exploration of identity. Kate’s struggle to reconcile who she was before her disappearance with who she became during those 11 years, and who she is now, is profoundly moving. It made me reflect on my own journey as a writer and how each story I tell shapes and changes me in subtle ways.

The ending of “When She Returned” left me with mixed feelings. Without giving away spoilers, I’ll say that while it was satisfying in many ways, there were threads left dangling that I wished had been tied up more neatly. However, perhaps that’s the point – in real life, not everything gets a neat resolution. As a writer, I’m still grappling with how to balance the desire for closure with the messy reality of human existence.

Would I recommend this book? Absolutely, but with a caveat. If you’re looking for a straightforward thriller with clear-cut heroes and villains, this might not be for you. But if you’re willing to dive into the murky waters of human psychology, to question your own perceptions and biases, then “When She Returned” offers a compelling journey.

As I set the book down, I found myself reaching for my notebook, jotting down ideas and questions inspired by Berry’s work. That, to me, is the mark of a truly impactful read – one that stays with you long after you’ve turned the last page, challenging you to think differently about the world and your place in it.When She Returned by Lucinda Berry3

In the end, “When She Returned” is more than just a psychological thriller. It’s a profound exploration of family, identity, and the lengths we go to protect the ones we love – even from ourselves. It’s a reminder that the truth is often more complex and nuanced than we’d like to believe, a lesson that I’ll carry with me not just in my writing, but in my everyday life as well.

As I return to my own manuscript, I find myself inspired to dig deeper, to push harder against the boundaries of conventional storytelling. Lucinda Berry’s “When She Returned” has not only entertained me but also challenged me as a writer and a human being. And isn’t that what great literature is all about?

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top